23 Comments
User's avatar
Lydia Lozano's avatar

Mr. Wellmann, that essay of yours is the best thing I have read this summer. Thank you so much. β€œThe first step in liquidating a people is to erase its memory. Destroy its books, its culture, its history. Then have someone write new books, manufacture a new culture, invent a new history. Before long the nation will begin to forget what it is and what it was.” ― Milan Kundera Not only a nation, but all of Western civilization.

Jan Wellmann's avatar

Thank you Lydia, you just made me an inch taller 🫑

Vicky's avatar

Superb article. You are right. Not seeing the film is an act of defiance against a world that is heading in a scary and horrific direction.

Ashok Awasthi's avatar

Excellent article Jan and that’s an understatement. Your brilliant piece has captured the evolution of CRT at its roots. In a way Frankfurt School is seeking to create an Ubermensch today by creating a blueprint of an ideal man and forcing everyone to confirm. The attempt by CRT to change our past is analogous to CIA’s program you beautifully outlined. This is being reinforced by AI which seeks to change historical characters identity to ensure conformity.

Troll Hunter's avatar

Hillsdale College will be doing it's own online FACTUAL (and free) class on The Odyssey to counter this pop-culture attack on Western civilization, hopefully before "The Idiocy" can do too much damage to further rot what's left of the peons' alleged brains.

Rob (c137)'s avatar

If only hillsdale could do a course on what Jesus taught actually goes against what modern Christianity has become, including the pro war narrative.

But then they would piss off their pay pigs. 🀣

Troll Hunter's avatar

Hillsdale collects the money for it's free online courses from the people who want to take them, i.e. folks like you (well, okay--I don't know about YOU, l.o.l.), and me. The class you are proposing is a commentary on the course of Christianity's history and how humans have shaped, or mis-shaped it- and not on what Christ actually taught. Most of us adults in the room learned the difference 40+ years ago :-) If you don't agree that Hillsdale's courses are providing a comparatively sane point of view on the topic of human nature as contrasted with the currently fashionable Progressive Leftist bee ess, you can always jump back on that radical Leftists' bandwagon. Alternatively, you can just re-read The Odyssey-- you know, the part where Oddyseus is warned by Circe about trying to fight Every Last Little Thing, because YOU CAN'T win 'em all. Duh.

Rob (c137)'s avatar

I'm not on either side. They both screwed us. I gave up on voting by party. I vote on issues like stopping illegal wars and against corporate control of government.

They're both gangs

DemoCRIPS and RepubliBLOODS

🀣

Troll Hunter's avatar

"I'm for No One!" 🀣🀣🀣

Rob (c137)'s avatar

That's the trick both parties play.

The illusion of choice.

When the Republicans impeached Clinton they didn't go after him for his actual crimes, they put on a show with the Lewinsky affair.

When the Democrats wanted to impeach Trump, they didn't go after the emoluments clause he violated.

And you can see how in Congress, both parties profit from war with insider trading. Neither side wants to stop conflicts of interest.

Meanwhile civil servants can lose their jobs and pensions for conflicts of interest.

Politics is like WWE pro wrestling, where on the stage they're fighting each other but backstage, they all work for the same bosses.

Trump was once in the WWE. 🀣

Jac Miller's avatar

Read as a fatalistic tale, a factual one, wrapped up with a glimmer of Homeric Hope. The Fourth Turning is alive and the wise

search the detritus for a kernel of inspiration.

Troll Hunter's avatar

Naaaah-- "They" just have the "megaphone," for the time being. But we know just what "story" they keep broadcasting, eh ;-)

Derek Hanrahan's avatar

Thanks for the extensive history, and the insights. Very coherent.

John Merryman's avatar

Possibly we need to understand the basic physics of why we get sucked down these rabbit holes. That structure is recursive and the feedback loops need the occasional circuit breakers to maintain contact with context.

https://substack.com/@johnmerryman/p-193985079

Andrew N's avatar

Thanks for a great article.

Really enjoying this substack's analysis of Homer

https://armenikus.substack.com/p/join-the-odyssey-read-along-may-july

Troll Hunter's avatar

Excellent! Along with the actual Odyssey, as well as Frankenstein's Monster, 1984 and Brave New World, this post needs to be read in every high school English class in the U.S.

Jerad's avatar

Like you, I’m just stoked to see the movie!

Troll Hunter's avatar

L.o.l.-- Unlike most of "yous," I'M stoked to REREAD The Oddysey, and not the "critical" post-modernist bull$hit Victims' version--!!!

Jerad's avatar

What is your favorite translation? I like the Lattimore for the Iliad, but enjoy Fitzgerald more with the Odyssey. How about you?

Cheerio's avatar

Wow this was very well written!